It looks like this is a web page, not a feed. I looked for a feed associated with this page, but couldn't find one. Please enter the address of your feed to validate.

Source: https://blog-225008253050.mit-edu.top/post/0534281769

  1. <!doctype html>
  2. <html xmlns="http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml" xml:lang="en" lang="en" prefix="og: http://ogp.me/ns#">
  3.  
  4.  <head>
  5.    <meta charset="utf-8">
  6.    <meta name="applicable-device" content="pc,mobile">
  7.    <meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width, initial-scale=1">
  8.    <title>The Influence of Social Comparison Mechanics on In-Game Behavior #085082633756 (2025-02-06)</title>
  9.    <link rel="canonical" href="https://blog-225008253050.mit-edu.top/post/0534281769">
  10.    <link rel="stylesheet" href="https://fonts.googleapis.com/css2?family=Poppins:wght@400;700&display=swap">
  11.    <link rel="stylesheet" href="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/css/style.css">
  12.    <script src="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/js/lazysizes.min.js" async></script>
  13.    <link rel="shortcut icon" href="/favicon.ico">
  14.    <!-- Open Graph Metadata -->
  15.    <meta property="og:type" content="article" />
  16.    <meta property="og:title" content="The Influence of Social Comparison Mechanics on In-Game Behavior" />
  17.    <meta property="og:description" content="The Influence of Social Comparison Mechanics on In-Game Behavior #085082633756 (2025-02-06)" />
  18.    <meta property="og:url" content="https://blog-225008253050.mit-edu.top/post/0534281769" />
  19.    <meta property="og:site_name" content="mit-edu.top" />
  20.    <meta property="og:image" content="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/images/post/17.jpg" />
  21.    <meta property="og:article:published_time" content="2025-02-05T17:07:24Z" />
  22.    <meta property="og:article:author" content="Dr. Christopher Robinson" />
  23.    <meta property="og:article:section" content="mit-edu.top" />
  24.    <meta property="og:article:tag" content="Games, Mobile Games, Video Games" />
  25.    <!-- Schema.org -->
  26.    <script type="application/ld+json">{
  27.            "@context": "https://schema.org",
  28.            "@type": "ScholarlyArticle",
  29.            "headline": "The Influence of Social Comparison Mechanics on In-Game Behavior #085082633756 (2025-02-06)",
  30.            "author": {
  31.                "@type": "Person",
  32.                "name": "Dr. Christopher Robinson",
  33.                "affiliation": {
  34.                    "@type": "Organization",
  35.                    "name": "mit-edu.top"
  36.                },
  37.                "url": "https://blog-225008253050.mit-edu.top/post/0534281769"
  38.            },
  39.            "datePublished": "2025-02-05T17:07:24Z",
  40.            "image": "https://x.mit-edu.top/static/images/post/17.jpg",
  41.            "journal": {
  42.                "@type": "Periodical",
  43.                "name": "mit-edu.top",
  44.                "issn": "10.1069/085082633756"
  45.            },
  46.            "publisher": {
  47.                "@type": "Organization",
  48.                "name": "mit-edu.top",
  49.                "url": "https://blog-225008253050.mit-edu.top"
  50.            },
  51.            "doi": "085082633756",
  52.            "abstract": "The Influence of Social Comparison Mechanics on In-Game Behavior #085082633756 (2025-02-06)",
  53.            "citation": {
  54.                "@type": "CreativeWork",
  55.                "name": "The Influence of Social Comparison Mechanics on In-Game Behavior",
  56.                "author": "Dr. Christopher Robinson",
  57.                "datePublished": "2025-02-05T17:07:24Z",
  58.                "url": "https://blog-225008253050.mit-edu.top/post/0534281769"
  59.            }
  60.        }
  61.    </script>
  62. </head>
  63.  
  64. <body>
  65.    <div class="site-mobile-menu site-navbar-target">
  66.        <div class="site-mobile-menu-header">
  67.            <div class="site-mobile-menu-close">
  68.                <span class="icofont-close js-menu-toggle"></span>
  69.            </div>
  70.        </div>
  71.        <div class="site-mobile-menu-body"></div>
  72.    </div>
  73.    <nav class="site-nav">
  74.        <div class="container">
  75.            <div class="site-navigation">
  76.                <div class="row">
  77.                    <div class="col-md-6 text-center order-1 order-md-2 mb-3 mb-md-0">
  78.                        <a href="https://blog-225008253050.mit-edu.top" class="logo m-0 text-uppercase">mit-edu.top</a>
  79.                    </div>
  80.                    <div class="col-md-3 order-3 order-md-1">
  81.                    </div>
  82.                </div>
  83.            </div>
  84.        </div>
  85.    </nav>
  86.    <div class="section post-section pt-5">
  87.        <div class="container">
  88.            <div class="row justify-content-center">
  89.                <div class="col-lg-8">
  90.                    <div class="text-center">
  91.                        <img src="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/images/user/15.jpg" alt="The Influence of Social Comparison Mechanics on In-Game Behavior" title="The Influence of Social Comparison Mechanics on In-Game Behavior" class="author-pic img-fluid rounded-circle mx-auto">
  92.                    </div>
  93.                    <span class="d-block text-center">Christopher Robinson</span>
  94.                    <span class="date d-block text-center small text-uppercase text-black-50 mb-5">2025-02-06</span>
  95.                    <h2 class="heading text-center">The Influence of Social Comparison Mechanics on In-Game Behavior</h2>
  96.                    <p class="lead mb-4 text-center">Thanks to Christopher Robinson for contributing the article "The Influence of Social Comparison Mechanics on In-Game Behavior".
  97.                    </p>
  98.                    <img src="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/images/post/17.jpg" alt="The Influence of Social Comparison Mechanics on In-Game Behavior" title="The Influence of Social Comparison Mechanics on In-Game Behavior" class="img-fluid rounded mb-4 lazyload">
  99.                    <p>This paper examines the integration of artificial intelligence (AI) in the design of mobile games, focusing on how AI enables adaptive game mechanics that adjust to a player’s behavior. The research explores how machine learning algorithms personalize game difficulty, enhance NPC interactions, and create procedurally generated content. It also addresses challenges in ensuring that AI-driven systems maintain fairness and avoid reinforcing harmful stereotypes.</p>
  100. <p>This study explores the use of mobile games as tools for political activism and social movements, focusing on how game mechanics can raise awareness about social, environmental, and political issues. By analyzing games that tackle topics such as climate change, racial justice, and gender equality, the paper investigates how game designers incorporate messages of activism into gameplay, narrative structures, and player decisions. The research also examines the potential for mobile games to inspire real-world action, fostering solidarity and collective mobilization through interactive digital experiences. The study offers a critical evaluation of the ethical implications of gamifying serious social issues, particularly in relation to authenticity, message dilution, and exploitation.</p>
  101. <p>This study investigates how mobile games can encourage physical activity among players, focusing on games that incorporate movement and exercise. It evaluates the effectiveness of these games in promoting health and fitness. </p>
  102. <p>Mobile gaming has democratized access to gaming experiences, empowering billions of smartphone users to dive into a vast array of games ranging from casual puzzles to graphically intensive adventures. The portability and convenience of mobile devices have transformed downtime into playtime, allowing gamers to indulge their passion anytime, anywhere, with a tap of their fingertips.</p>
  103. <p>This study explores the economic implications of in-game microtransactions within mobile games, focusing on their effects on user behavior and virtual market dynamics. The research investigates how the implementation of microtransactions, including loot boxes, subscriptions, and cosmetic purchases, influences player engagement, game retention, and overall spending patterns. By drawing on theories of consumer behavior, behavioral economics, and market structure, the paper analyzes how mobile game developers create virtual economies that mimic real-world market forces. Additionally, the paper discusses the ethical implications of microtransactions, particularly in terms of player manipulation, gambling-like mechanics, and the impact on younger audiences.</p>
  104.  
  105.                    <p>
  106.                    <a href="/redirect/?url=https://blog-225008253050.mit-edu.top/post/0534281769" target="_blank" class="custom-link">Link</a>
  107.                    </p>
  108.                    <p><a href="https://www.linegames.org/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  109. <a href="https://www.iliiili.com/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  110. <a href="https://www.digwow.net/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  111. <a href="https://www.free-giftcodes.com/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  112. <a href="https://www.gifthub.com.ru/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  113. <a href="https://871663547554-edu.iliiili.com/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  114. <a href="https://206227070739-edu.digwow.net/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  115. <a href="https://306595083240-edu.free-giftcodes.com/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  116. <a href="https://604360891423-edu.gifthub.com.ru/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  117. <a href="https://230204144794-gov.iliiili.com/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  118. <a href="https://302727788224-gov.digwow.net/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  119. <a href="https://203345768799-gov.free-giftcodes.com/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  120. <a href="https://103583023296-gov.gifthub.com.ru/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  121. <a href="https://065887217642-gov-edu.iliiili.com/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  122. <a href="https://128097918266-gov-edu.digwow.net/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  123. <a href="https://568997504193-gov-edu.free-giftcodes.com/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  124. <a href="https://814689891791-gov-edu.gifthub.com.ru/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  125. <a href="https://492319976866-edu.iliiili.com/?url=https://blog-225008253050.mit-edu.top/post/0534281769" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  126. <a href="https://627136427986-edu.digwow.net/?url=https://blog-225008253050.mit-edu.top/post/0534281769" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  127. <a href="https://965135284526-edu.free-giftcodes.com/?url=https://blog-225008253050.mit-edu.top/post/0534281769" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  128. <a href="https://513100862576-edu.gifthub.com.ru/?url=https://blog-225008253050.mit-edu.top/post/0534281769" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  129. <a href="https://128917514127-gov.iliiili.com/?url=https://blog-225008253050.mit-edu.top/post/0534281769" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  130. <a href="https://656108750070-gov.digwow.net/?url=https://blog-225008253050.mit-edu.top/post/0534281769" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  131. <a href="https://057314027918-gov.free-giftcodes.com/?url=https://blog-225008253050.mit-edu.top/post/0534281769" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  132. <a href="https://679082847557-gov.gifthub.com.ru/?url=https://blog-225008253050.mit-edu.top/post/0534281769" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  133. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?333431547288&amp;url=https://blog-225008253050.mit-edu.top/post/0534281769" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  134. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?780572339347&amp;url=https://naver780572339347-edu.digwow.net" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  135. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?521277010454&amp;url=https://naver521277010454-edu.iliiili.com" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  136. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?619347126173&amp;url=https://naver619347126173-edu.1717173.xyz" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  137. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?417341004231&amp;url=https://naver417341004231-edu.gifthub.com.ru" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  138. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?043189540484&amp;url=https://naver043189540484-gov.digwow.net" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  139. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?297814155990&amp;url=https://naver297814155990-gov.iliiili.com" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  140. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?100524738047&amp;url=https://naver100524738047-gov.1717173.xyz" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  141. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?992040569241&amp;url=https://naver992040569241-gov.gifthub.com.ru" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  142. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?667266276339&amp;url=https://naver667266276339-gov-edu.digwow.net" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  143. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?702517216411&amp;url=https://naver702517216411-gov-edu.iliiili.com" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  144. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?567491658384&amp;url=https://naver567491658384-gov-edu.1717173.xyz" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  145. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?911655526887&amp;url=https://naver911655526887-gov-edu.gifthub.com.ru" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  146. <a href="https://blog-519260317066.gifthub.news/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  147. <a href="https://blog-222050552717.jp-edu.sbs/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  148. <a href="https://blog-279858609536.kr-edu.sbs/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  149. <a href="https://blog-667374097202.krlinkedin.sbs/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  150. <a href="https://blog-358539256232.mit-edu.sbs/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  151. <a href="https://blog-002056612459.mit-edu.buzz/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  152. <a href="https://blog-859679905758.mit-edu.tech/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  153. <a href="https://blog-684308508804.mit-edu.site/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  154. <a href="https://blog-475711606674.mit-edu.top/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  155. <a href="https://blog-664130009549.usa-gov.top/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  156. <a href="https://research-399280638109.mit-edu.pp.ua/?url=https://blog-225008253050.mit-edu.top/post/0534281769" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  157. <a href="https://research-270937393817.harvard-edu.pp.ua/?url=https://blog-225008253050.mit-edu.top/post/0534281769" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  158. <a href="https://research-927871711739.stanford-edu.pp.ua/?url=https://blog-225008253050.mit-edu.top/post/0534281769" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  159. <a href="https://research-893614641635.cambridge-edu.pp.ua/?url=https://blog-225008253050.mit-edu.top/post/0534281769" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  160. <a href="https://research-465856549337.berkeley-edu.pp.ua/?url=https://blog-225008253050.mit-edu.top/post/0534281769" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  161. <a href="https://research-408581561922.oxford-edu.pp.ua/?url=https://blog-225008253050.mit-edu.top/post/0534281769" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  162. <a href="https://research-386550007592-edu.wwv.pp.ua/?url=https://blog-225008253050.mit-edu.top/post/0534281769" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  163. <a href="https://research-257180821689-edu.sean.pp.ua/?url=https://blog-225008253050.mit-edu.top/post/0534281769" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  164. <a href="https://research-846039278923-edu.line.pp.ua/?url=https://blog-225008253050.mit-edu.top/post/0534281769" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  165. </p>
  166.                    <div class="row mt-5 pt-5 border-top">
  167.                    </div>
  168.                </div>
  169.            </div>
  170.        </div>
  171.    </div>
  172.    <div class="section pb-0">
  173.        <div class="container">
  174.            <div class="row">
  175.                <div class="col-lg-12">
  176.                    <h2 class="heading">Related</h2>
  177.                </div>
  178.            </div>
  179.            <div class="row justify-content-center">
  180.                <div class="col-lg-12">
  181.                    <div class="post-entry d-md-flex small-horizontal mb-5">
  182.                        <div class="me-md-5 thumbnail mb-3 mb-md-0">
  183.                            <a href="https://blog-225008253050.mit-edu.top/post/4892016537">
  184.                            <img src="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/images/post/17.jpg" alt="Mobile Games as Platforms for Interactive Environmental Education" title="Mobile Games as Platforms for Interactive Environmental Education" class="img-fluid lazyload">
  185.                            </a>
  186.                        </div>
  187.                        <div class="content">
  188.                            <div class="post-meta mb-3">
  189.                                <a href="https://blog-4892016537.mit-edu.top/post/4892016537/" target="_blank">
  190.                                <span class="date">2025-02-06</span>
  191.                                </a>
  192.                            </div>
  193.                            <h2 class="heading"><a href="https://blog-225008253050.mit-edu.top/post/4892016537">Mobile Games as Platforms for Interactive Environmental Education</a></h2>
  194.                            <p class="info">This study explores the challenges and opportunities associated with cross-platform play in mobile games, where players can interact with others across different gaming devices, such as consoles, PCs, and smartphones. The research examines the technical, social, and business challenges of integrating cross-platform functionality, including issues related to server synchronization, input compatibility, and player matching. The paper also investigates how cross-platform play influences player engagement, community building, and game longevity, as well as the potential for cross-platform competitions and esports. Drawing on user experience research and platform integration strategies, the study provides recommendations for developers looking to implement cross-platform play in a way that enhances player experiences and extends the lifecycle of mobile games.</p>
  195.                            <a href="https://blog-225008253050.mit-edu.top/post/4892016537" class="post-author d-flex align-items-center">
  196.                                <div class="author-pic">
  197.                                    <img src="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/images/user/15.jpg" alt="Mobile Games as Platforms for Interactive Environmental Education" title="Mobile Games as Platforms for Interactive Environmental Education" class="lazyload">
  198.                                </div>
  199.                                <div class="text">
  200.                                    <strong>Michelle Turner</strong>
  201.                                    <span>2025-02-06 published post</span>
  202.                                </div>
  203.                            </a>
  204.                        </div>
  205.                    </div>
  206.                </div>
  207.                <div class="col-lg-12">
  208.                    <div class="post-entry d-md-flex small-horizontal mb-5">
  209.                        <div class="me-md-5 thumbnail mb-3 mb-md-0">
  210.                            <a href="https://blog-225008253050.mit-edu.top/post/6029543187">
  211.                            <img src="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/images/post/12.jpg" alt="Exploring Linguistic Nuances in Game-Based Communication Systems" title="Exploring Linguistic Nuances in Game-Based Communication Systems" class="img-fluid lazyload">
  212.                            </a>
  213.                        </div>
  214.                        <div class="content">
  215.                            <div class="post-meta mb-3">
  216.                                <a href="https://blog-6029543187.mit-edu.top/post/6029543187/" target="_blank">
  217.                                <span class="date">2025-02-06</span>
  218.                                </a>
  219.                            </div>
  220.                            <h2 class="heading"><a href="https://blog-225008253050.mit-edu.top/post/6029543187">Exploring Linguistic Nuances in Game-Based Communication Systems</a></h2>
  221.                            <p class="info">This paper examines the growth and sustainability of mobile esports within the broader competitive gaming ecosystem. The research investigates the rise of mobile esports tournaments, platforms, and streaming services, focusing on how mobile games like League of Legends: Wild Rift, PUBG Mobile, and Free Fire are becoming major players in the esports industry. Drawing on theories of sports management, media studies, and digital economies, the study explores the factors contributing to the success of mobile esports, such as accessibility, mobile-first design, and player demographics. The research also considers the future challenges of mobile esports, including monetization, player welfare, and the potential for integration with traditional esports leagues.</p>
  222.                            <a href="https://blog-225008253050.mit-edu.top/post/6029543187" class="post-author d-flex align-items-center">
  223.                                <div class="author-pic">
  224.                                    <img src="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/images/user/20.jpg" alt="Exploring Linguistic Nuances in Game-Based Communication Systems" title="Exploring Linguistic Nuances in Game-Based Communication Systems" class="lazyload">
  225.                                </div>
  226.                                <div class="text">
  227.                                    <strong>Jacob Murphy</strong>
  228.                                    <span>2025-02-06 published post</span>
  229.                                </div>
  230.                            </a>
  231.                        </div>
  232.                    </div>
  233.                </div>
  234.                <div class="col-lg-12">
  235.                    <div class="post-entry d-md-flex small-horizontal mb-5">
  236.                        <div class="me-md-5 thumbnail mb-3 mb-md-0">
  237.                            <a href="https://blog-225008253050.mit-edu.top/post/0842971356">
  238.                            <img src="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/images/post/15.jpg" alt="Exploring Mixed Reality Game Mechanics in Urban Environments" title="Exploring Mixed Reality Game Mechanics in Urban Environments" class="img-fluid lazyload">
  239.                            </a>
  240.                        </div>
  241.                        <div class="content">
  242.                            <div class="post-meta mb-3">
  243.                                <a href="https://blog-0842971356.mit-edu.top/post/0842971356/" target="_blank">
  244.                                <span class="date">2025-02-06</span>
  245.                                </a>
  246.                            </div>
  247.                            <h2 class="heading"><a href="https://blog-225008253050.mit-edu.top/post/0842971356">Exploring Mixed Reality Game Mechanics in Urban Environments</a></h2>
  248.                            <p class="info">A Comparative Analysis This paper provides a comprehensive analysis of various monetization models in mobile gaming, including in-app purchases, advertisements, and subscription services. It compares the effectiveness and ethical considerations of each model, offering recommendations for developers and policymakers.</p>
  249.                            <a href="https://blog-225008253050.mit-edu.top/post/0842971356" class="post-author d-flex align-items-center">
  250.                                <div class="author-pic">
  251.                                    <img src="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/images/user/9.jpg" alt="Exploring Mixed Reality Game Mechanics in Urban Environments" title="Exploring Mixed Reality Game Mechanics in Urban Environments" class="lazyload">
  252.                                </div>
  253.                                <div class="text">
  254.                                    <strong>Maria Anderson</strong>
  255.                                    <span>2025-02-06 published post</span>
  256.                                </div>
  257.                            </a>
  258.                        </div>
  259.                    </div>
  260.                </div>
  261.            </div>
  262.        </div>
  263.    </div>
  264.    <div class="py-5 bg-light mx-md-3 sec-subscribe">
  265.        <div class="container">
  266.            <div class="row">
  267.                <div class="col-lg-12">
  268.                    <h2 class="h4 fw-bold">Subscribe to newsletter</h2>
  269.                </div>
  270.            </div>
  271.            <form class="row">
  272.                <div class="col-md-8">
  273.                    <div class="mb-3 mb-md-0">
  274.                        <input type="email" class="form-control" placeholder="Enter your email">
  275.                    </div>
  276.                </div>
  277.                <div class="col-md-4 d-grid">
  278.                    <input type="submit" class="btn btn-primary" value="Subscribe">
  279.                </div>
  280.            </form>
  281.        </div>
  282.    </div>
  283.    <div class="site-footer">
  284.        <div class="container">
  285.            <div class="row justify-content-center copyright">
  286.                <div class="col-lg-7 text-center">
  287.                    <div class="widget">
  288.                        <p>Copyright &copy;
  289.                            <script>document.write(new Date().getFullYear());</script> All rights reserved.
  290.                        </p>
  291. <p>
  292.    < Top VPS Hosting Choice ><br>
  293.    <a href="https://evolution-host.com?ref=DQgZ6P" target="_blank">
  294.        <img src="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/images/evolution-host.png" alt="Evolution Host" title="Evolution Host" class="evhost lazyload">
  295.    </a>
  296. </p>
  297.                    </div>
  298.                </div>
  299.            </div>
  300.        </div>
  301.    </div>
  302. </body>
  303.  
  304. </html>
Copyright © 2002-9 Sam Ruby, Mark Pilgrim, Joseph Walton, and Phil Ringnalda