It looks like this is a web page, not a feed. I looked for a feed associated with this page, but couldn't find one. Please enter the address of your feed to validate.

Source: https://blog-9126853704.mit-edu.top/post/6902148537

  1. <!doctype html>
  2. <html xmlns="http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml" xml:lang="en" lang="en" prefix="og: http://ogp.me/ns#">
  3.  
  4.  <head>
  5.    <meta charset="utf-8">
  6.    <meta name="applicable-device" content="pc,mobile">
  7.    <meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width, initial-scale=1">
  8.    <title>Monetization Strategies in Gacha Games: A Game-Theoretic Approach #393988697449 (2025-02-01)</title>
  9.    <link rel="canonical" href="https://blog-9126853704.mit-edu.top/post/6902148537">
  10.    <link rel="stylesheet" href="https://fonts.googleapis.com/css2?family=Poppins:wght@400;700&display=swap">
  11.    <link rel="stylesheet" href="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/css/style.css">
  12.    <script src="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/js/lazysizes.min.js" async></script>
  13.    <link rel="shortcut icon" href="/favicon.ico">
  14.    <!-- Open Graph Metadata -->
  15.    <meta property="og:type" content="article" />
  16.    <meta property="og:title" content="Monetization Strategies in Gacha Games: A Game-Theoretic Approach" />
  17.    <meta property="og:description" content="Monetization Strategies in Gacha Games: A Game-Theoretic Approach #393988697449 (2025-02-01)" />
  18.    <meta property="og:url" content="https://blog-9126853704.mit-edu.top/post/6902148537" />
  19.    <meta property="og:site_name" content="mit-edu.top" />
  20.    <meta property="og:image" content="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/images/post/8.jpg" />
  21.    <meta property="og:article:published_time" content="2025-02-01T11:50:29Z" />
  22.    <meta property="og:article:author" content="Dr. Pamela Kelly" />
  23.    <meta property="og:article:section" content="mit-edu.top" />
  24.    <meta property="og:article:tag" content="Games, Mobile Games, Video Games" />
  25.    <!-- Schema.org -->
  26.    <script type="application/ld+json">{
  27.            "@context": "https://schema.org",
  28.            "@type": "ScholarlyArticle",
  29.            "headline": "Monetization Strategies in Gacha Games: A Game-Theoretic Approach #393988697449 (2025-02-01)",
  30.            "author": {
  31.                "@type": "Person",
  32.                "name": "Dr. Pamela Kelly",
  33.                "affiliation": {
  34.                    "@type": "Organization",
  35.                    "name": "mit-edu.top"
  36.                },
  37.                "url": "https://blog-9126853704.mit-edu.top/post/6902148537"
  38.            },
  39.            "datePublished": "2025-02-01T11:50:29Z",
  40.            "image": "https://x.mit-edu.top/static/images/post/8.jpg",
  41.            "journal": {
  42.                "@type": "Periodical",
  43.                "name": "mit-edu.top",
  44.                "issn": "10.1069/393988697449"
  45.            },
  46.            "publisher": {
  47.                "@type": "Organization",
  48.                "name": "mit-edu.top",
  49.                "url": "https://blog-9126853704.mit-edu.top"
  50.            },
  51.            "doi": "393988697449",
  52.            "abstract": "Monetization Strategies in Gacha Games: A Game-Theoretic Approach #393988697449 (2025-02-01)",
  53.            "citation": {
  54.                "@type": "CreativeWork",
  55.                "name": "Monetization Strategies in Gacha Games: A Game-Theoretic Approach",
  56.                "author": "Dr. Pamela Kelly",
  57.                "datePublished": "2025-02-01T11:50:29Z",
  58.                "url": "https://blog-9126853704.mit-edu.top/post/6902148537"
  59.            }
  60.        }
  61.    </script>
  62. </head>
  63.  
  64. <body>
  65.    <div class="site-mobile-menu site-navbar-target">
  66.        <div class="site-mobile-menu-header">
  67.            <div class="site-mobile-menu-close">
  68.                <span class="icofont-close js-menu-toggle"></span>
  69.            </div>
  70.        </div>
  71.        <div class="site-mobile-menu-body"></div>
  72.    </div>
  73.    <nav class="site-nav">
  74.        <div class="container">
  75.            <div class="site-navigation">
  76.                <div class="row">
  77.                    <div class="col-md-6 text-center order-1 order-md-2 mb-3 mb-md-0">
  78.                        <a href="https://blog-9126853704.mit-edu.top" class="logo m-0 text-uppercase">mit-edu.top</a>
  79.                    </div>
  80.                    <div class="col-md-3 order-3 order-md-1">
  81.                    </div>
  82.                </div>
  83.            </div>
  84.        </div>
  85.    </nav>
  86.    <div class="section post-section pt-5">
  87.        <div class="container">
  88.            <div class="row justify-content-center">
  89.                <div class="col-lg-8">
  90.                    <div class="text-center">
  91.                        <img src="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/images/user/13.jpg" alt="Monetization Strategies in Gacha Games: A Game-Theoretic Approach" title="Monetization Strategies in Gacha Games: A Game-Theoretic Approach" class="author-pic img-fluid rounded-circle mx-auto">
  92.                    </div>
  93.                    <span class="d-block text-center">Pamela Kelly</span>
  94.                    <span class="date d-block text-center small text-uppercase text-black-50 mb-5">2025-02-01</span>
  95.                    <h2 class="heading text-center">Monetization Strategies in Gacha Games: A Game-Theoretic Approach</h2>
  96.                    <p class="lead mb-4 text-center">Thanks to Pamela Kelly for contributing the article "Monetization Strategies in Gacha Games: A Game-Theoretic Approach".
  97.                    </p>
  98.                    <img src="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/images/post/8.jpg" alt="Monetization Strategies in Gacha Games: A Game-Theoretic Approach" title="Monetization Strategies in Gacha Games: A Game-Theoretic Approach" class="img-fluid rounded mb-4 lazyload">
  99.                    <p>Gaming's impact on education is profound, with gamified learning platforms revolutionizing how students engage with academic content. By incorporating game elements such as rewards, challenges, and progression systems into educational software, educators are able to make learning more interactive, enjoyable, and effective, catering to diverse learning styles and enhancing retention rates.</p>
  100. <p>This research examines the convergence of mobile gaming and virtual reality (VR) technologies, focusing on how the integration of VR into mobile games can create immersive, interactive experiences for players. The study explores the technical challenges of VR gaming on mobile devices, including hardware limitations, motion tracking, and user comfort, as well as the design principles that enable seamless interaction between virtual environments and physical spaces. The paper investigates the cognitive and emotional effects of VR gaming, particularly in relation to presence, immersion, and player agency. It also addresses the potential for VR to revolutionize mobile gaming experiences, creating new opportunities for storytelling, social interaction, and entertainment.</p>
  101. <p>This study leverages mobile game analytics and predictive modeling techniques to explore how player behavior data can be used to enhance monetization strategies and retention rates. The research employs machine learning algorithms to analyze patterns in player interactions, purchase behaviors, and in-game progression, with the goal of forecasting player lifetime value and identifying factors contributing to player churn. The paper offers insights into how game developers can optimize their revenue models through targeted in-game offers, personalized content, and adaptive difficulty settings, while also discussing the ethical implications of data collection and algorithmic decision-making in the gaming industry.</p>
  102. <p>This research examines how mobile gaming facilitates social interactions among players, focusing on community building, communication patterns, and the formation of virtual identities. It also considers the implications of mobile gaming on social behavior and relationships.</p>
  103. <p>This study investigates the economic systems within mobile games, focusing on the development of virtual economies, marketplaces, and the integration of real-world currencies in digital spaces. The research explores how mobile games have created virtual goods markets, where players can buy, sell, and trade in-game assets for real money. By applying economic theories related to virtual currencies, supply and demand, and market regulation, the paper analyzes the implications of these digital economies for the gaming industry and broader digital commerce. The study also addresses the ethical considerations of monetization models, such as microtransactions, loot boxes, and the implications for player welfare.</p>
  104.  
  105.                    <p>
  106.                    <a href="/redirect/?url=https://blog-9126853704.mit-edu.top/post/6902148537" target="_blank" class="custom-link">Link</a>
  107.                    </p>
  108.                    <p><a href="https://www.linegames.org/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  109. <a href="https://www.iliiili.com/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  110. <a href="https://www.digwow.net/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  111. <a href="https://www.free-giftcodes.com/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  112. <a href="https://www.gifthub.com.ru/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  113. <a href="https://707695445107-edu.iliiili.com/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  114. <a href="https://617469115848-edu.digwow.net/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  115. <a href="https://655224804663-edu.free-giftcodes.com/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  116. <a href="https://208728489136-edu.gifthub.com.ru/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  117. <a href="https://147732507020-gov.iliiili.com/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  118. <a href="https://400967288160-gov.digwow.net/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  119. <a href="https://909923647311-gov.free-giftcodes.com/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  120. <a href="https://571283334420-gov.gifthub.com.ru/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  121. <a href="https://159065166069-gov-edu.iliiili.com/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  122. <a href="https://423255313441-gov-edu.digwow.net/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  123. <a href="https://775117233230-gov-edu.free-giftcodes.com/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  124. <a href="https://756462305721-gov-edu.gifthub.com.ru/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  125. <a href="https://252507784206-edu.iliiili.com/?url=https://blog-9126853704.mit-edu.top/post/6902148537" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  126. <a href="https://030354339075-edu.digwow.net/?url=https://blog-9126853704.mit-edu.top/post/6902148537" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  127. <a href="https://315888904264-edu.free-giftcodes.com/?url=https://blog-9126853704.mit-edu.top/post/6902148537" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  128. <a href="https://933453156181-edu.gifthub.com.ru/?url=https://blog-9126853704.mit-edu.top/post/6902148537" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  129. <a href="https://524422053542-gov.iliiili.com/?url=https://blog-9126853704.mit-edu.top/post/6902148537" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  130. <a href="https://433869362617-gov.digwow.net/?url=https://blog-9126853704.mit-edu.top/post/6902148537" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  131. <a href="https://923632794236-gov.free-giftcodes.com/?url=https://blog-9126853704.mit-edu.top/post/6902148537" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  132. <a href="https://532996130427-gov.gifthub.com.ru/?url=https://blog-9126853704.mit-edu.top/post/6902148537" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  133. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?353614316770&amp;url=https://blog-9126853704.mit-edu.top/post/6902148537" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  134. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?959373036326&amp;url=https://naver959373036326-edu.digwow.net" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  135. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?930082718079&amp;url=https://naver930082718079-edu.iliiili.com" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  136. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?411198184122&amp;url=https://naver411198184122-edu.1717173.xyz" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  137. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?425157750859&amp;url=https://naver425157750859-edu.gifthub.com.ru" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  138. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?020838870999&amp;url=https://naver020838870999-gov.digwow.net" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  139. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?817320572088&amp;url=https://naver817320572088-gov.iliiili.com" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  140. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?864949852945&amp;url=https://naver864949852945-gov.1717173.xyz" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  141. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?723822814646&amp;url=https://naver723822814646-gov.gifthub.com.ru" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  142. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?604912799284&amp;url=https://naver604912799284-gov-edu.digwow.net" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  143. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?169463936329&amp;url=https://naver169463936329-gov-edu.iliiili.com" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  144. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?501066626117&amp;url=https://naver501066626117-gov-edu.1717173.xyz" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  145. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?497316832778&amp;url=https://naver497316832778-gov-edu.gifthub.com.ru" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  146. <a href="https://blog-172805765962.gifthub.news/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  147. <a href="https://blog-534146985727.jp-edu.sbs/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  148. <a href="https://blog-300688506886.kr-edu.sbs/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  149. <a href="https://blog-363950103528.krlinkedin.sbs/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  150. <a href="https://blog-227790430598.mit-edu.sbs/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  151. <a href="https://blog-449027754049.mit-edu.buzz/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  152. <a href="https://blog-150513345115.mit-edu.tech/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  153. <a href="https://blog-168228062065.mit-edu.site/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  154. <a href="https://blog-730145151103.mit-edu.top/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  155. <a href="https://blog-547159766598.usa-gov.top/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  156. <a href="https://research-404600174299.mit-edu.pp.ua/?url=https://blog-9126853704.mit-edu.top/post/6902148537" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  157. <a href="https://research-804025379194.harvard-edu.pp.ua/?url=https://blog-9126853704.mit-edu.top/post/6902148537" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  158. <a href="https://research-061620560931.stanford-edu.pp.ua/?url=https://blog-9126853704.mit-edu.top/post/6902148537" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  159. <a href="https://research-058578469861.cambridge-edu.pp.ua/?url=https://blog-9126853704.mit-edu.top/post/6902148537" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  160. <a href="https://research-309318825097.berkeley-edu.pp.ua/?url=https://blog-9126853704.mit-edu.top/post/6902148537" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  161. <a href="https://research-143236341199.oxford-edu.pp.ua/?url=https://blog-9126853704.mit-edu.top/post/6902148537" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  162. <a href="https://research-035922062093-edu.wwv.pp.ua/?url=https://blog-9126853704.mit-edu.top/post/6902148537" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  163. <a href="https://research-976475189503-edu.sean.pp.ua/?url=https://blog-9126853704.mit-edu.top/post/6902148537" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  164. <a href="https://research-137356250842-edu.line.pp.ua/?url=https://blog-9126853704.mit-edu.top/post/6902148537" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  165. </p>
  166.                    <div class="row mt-5 pt-5 border-top">
  167.                    </div>
  168.                </div>
  169.            </div>
  170.        </div>
  171.    </div>
  172.    <div class="section pb-0">
  173.        <div class="container">
  174.            <div class="row">
  175.                <div class="col-lg-12">
  176.                    <h2 class="heading">Related</h2>
  177.                </div>
  178.            </div>
  179.            <div class="row justify-content-center">
  180.                <div class="col-lg-12">
  181.                    <div class="post-entry d-md-flex small-horizontal mb-5">
  182.                        <div class="me-md-5 thumbnail mb-3 mb-md-0">
  183.                            <a href="https://blog-9126853704.mit-edu.top/post/5031928467">
  184.                            <img src="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/images/post/8.jpg" alt="Designing Educational Mobile Games for Cognitive Skill Development in Adolescents" title="Designing Educational Mobile Games for Cognitive Skill Development in Adolescents" class="img-fluid lazyload">
  185.                            </a>
  186.                        </div>
  187.                        <div class="content">
  188.                            <div class="post-meta mb-3">
  189.                                <a href="https://blog-5031928467.mit-edu.top/post/5031928467/" target="_blank">
  190.                                <span class="date">2025-02-01</span>
  191.                                </a>
  192.                            </div>
  193.                            <h2 class="heading"><a href="https://blog-9126853704.mit-edu.top/post/5031928467">Designing Educational Mobile Games for Cognitive Skill Development in Adolescents</a></h2>
  194.                            <p class="info">This study delves into the various strategies that mobile game developers use to maximize user retention, including personalized content, rewards systems, and social integration. It explores how data analytics are employed to track player behavior, predict churn, and optimize engagement strategies. The research also discusses the ethical concerns related to user tracking and retention tactics, proposing frameworks for responsible data use.</p>
  195.                            <a href="https://blog-9126853704.mit-edu.top/post/5031928467" class="post-author d-flex align-items-center">
  196.                                <div class="author-pic">
  197.                                    <img src="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/images/user/13.jpg" alt="Designing Educational Mobile Games for Cognitive Skill Development in Adolescents" title="Designing Educational Mobile Games for Cognitive Skill Development in Adolescents" class="lazyload">
  198.                                </div>
  199.                                <div class="text">
  200.                                    <strong>Judith Mitchell</strong>
  201.                                    <span>2025-02-01 published post</span>
  202.                                </div>
  203.                            </a>
  204.                        </div>
  205.                    </div>
  206.                </div>
  207.                <div class="col-lg-12">
  208.                    <div class="post-entry d-md-flex small-horizontal mb-5">
  209.                        <div class="me-md-5 thumbnail mb-3 mb-md-0">
  210.                            <a href="https://blog-9126853704.mit-edu.top/post/5318694720">
  211.                            <img src="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/images/post/1.jpg" alt="Hybrid Neural-Symbolic AI for Strategic Decision-Making in Game Environments" title="Hybrid Neural-Symbolic AI for Strategic Decision-Making in Game Environments" class="img-fluid lazyload">
  212.                            </a>
  213.                        </div>
  214.                        <div class="content">
  215.                            <div class="post-meta mb-3">
  216.                                <a href="https://blog-5318694720.mit-edu.top/post/5318694720/" target="_blank">
  217.                                <span class="date">2025-02-01</span>
  218.                                </a>
  219.                            </div>
  220.                            <h2 class="heading"><a href="https://blog-9126853704.mit-edu.top/post/5318694720">Hybrid Neural-Symbolic AI for Strategic Decision-Making in Game Environments</a></h2>
  221.                            <p class="info">This study explores the integration of augmented reality (AR) technologies in mobile games, examining how AR enhances user engagement and immersion. It discusses technical challenges, user acceptance, and the future potential of AR in mobile gaming.</p>
  222.                            <a href="https://blog-9126853704.mit-edu.top/post/5318694720" class="post-author d-flex align-items-center">
  223.                                <div class="author-pic">
  224.                                    <img src="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/images/user/5.jpg" alt="Hybrid Neural-Symbolic AI for Strategic Decision-Making in Game Environments" title="Hybrid Neural-Symbolic AI for Strategic Decision-Making in Game Environments" class="lazyload">
  225.                                </div>
  226.                                <div class="text">
  227.                                    <strong>Michael Davis</strong>
  228.                                    <span>2025-02-01 published post</span>
  229.                                </div>
  230.                            </a>
  231.                        </div>
  232.                    </div>
  233.                </div>
  234.                <div class="col-lg-12">
  235.                    <div class="post-entry d-md-flex small-horizontal mb-5">
  236.                        <div class="me-md-5 thumbnail mb-3 mb-md-0">
  237.                            <a href="https://blog-9126853704.mit-edu.top/post/0285971346">
  238.                            <img src="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/images/post/16.jpg" alt="Multi-Layer Consensus Mechanisms for Securing Game Asset Transactions" title="Multi-Layer Consensus Mechanisms for Securing Game Asset Transactions" class="img-fluid lazyload">
  239.                            </a>
  240.                        </div>
  241.                        <div class="content">
  242.                            <div class="post-meta mb-3">
  243.                                <a href="https://blog-0285971346.mit-edu.top/post/0285971346/" target="_blank">
  244.                                <span class="date">2025-02-01</span>
  245.                                </a>
  246.                            </div>
  247.                            <h2 class="heading"><a href="https://blog-9126853704.mit-edu.top/post/0285971346">Multi-Layer Consensus Mechanisms for Securing Game Asset Transactions</a></h2>
  248.                            <p class="info">This research investigates the potential of mobile games as tools for political engagement and civic education, focusing on how game mechanics can be used to teach democratic values, political participation, and social activism. The study compares gamified civic education games across different cultures and political systems, analyzing their effectiveness in fostering political literacy, voter participation, and civic responsibility. By applying frameworks from political science and education theory, the paper assesses the impact of mobile games on shaping young people's political beliefs and behaviors, while also examining the ethical implications of using games for political socialization.</p>
  249.                            <a href="https://blog-9126853704.mit-edu.top/post/0285971346" class="post-author d-flex align-items-center">
  250.                                <div class="author-pic">
  251.                                    <img src="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/images/user/7.jpg" alt="Multi-Layer Consensus Mechanisms for Securing Game Asset Transactions" title="Multi-Layer Consensus Mechanisms for Securing Game Asset Transactions" class="lazyload">
  252.                                </div>
  253.                                <div class="text">
  254.                                    <strong>Walter Hughes</strong>
  255.                                    <span>2025-02-01 published post</span>
  256.                                </div>
  257.                            </a>
  258.                        </div>
  259.                    </div>
  260.                </div>
  261.            </div>
  262.        </div>
  263.    </div>
  264.    <div class="py-5 bg-light mx-md-3 sec-subscribe">
  265.        <div class="container">
  266.            <div class="row">
  267.                <div class="col-lg-12">
  268.                    <h2 class="h4 fw-bold">Subscribe to newsletter</h2>
  269.                </div>
  270.            </div>
  271.            <form class="row">
  272.                <div class="col-md-8">
  273.                    <div class="mb-3 mb-md-0">
  274.                        <input type="email" class="form-control" placeholder="Enter your email">
  275.                    </div>
  276.                </div>
  277.                <div class="col-md-4 d-grid">
  278.                    <input type="submit" class="btn btn-primary" value="Subscribe">
  279.                </div>
  280.            </form>
  281.        </div>
  282.    </div>
  283.    <div class="site-footer">
  284.        <div class="container">
  285.            <div class="row justify-content-center copyright">
  286.                <div class="col-lg-7 text-center">
  287.                    <div class="widget">
  288.                        <p>Copyright &copy;
  289.                            <script>document.write(new Date().getFullYear());</script> All rights reserved.
  290.                        </p>
  291. <p>
  292.    < Top VPS Hosting Choice ><br>
  293.    <a href="https://evolution-host.com?ref=DQgZ6P" target="_blank">
  294.        <img src="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/images/evolution-host.png" alt="Evolution Host" title="Evolution Host" class="evhost lazyload">
  295.    </a>
  296. </p>
  297.                    </div>
  298.                </div>
  299.            </div>
  300.        </div>
  301.    </div>
  302. </body>
  303.  
  304. </html>
Copyright © 2002-9 Sam Ruby, Mark Pilgrim, Joseph Walton, and Phil Ringnalda