It looks like this is a web page, not a feed. I looked for a feed associated with this page, but couldn't find one. Please enter the address of your feed to validate.

Source: https://blog-9630758412.mit-edu.top/post/9630758412

  1. <!doctype html>
  2. <html xmlns="http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml" xml:lang="en" lang="en" prefix="og: http://ogp.me/ns#">
  3.  
  4.  <head>
  5.    <meta charset="utf-8">
  6.    <meta name="applicable-device" content="pc,mobile">
  7.    <meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width, initial-scale=1">
  8.    <title>Data-Driven Insights into Player Churn in Freemium Game Models #922337408791 (2025-01-31)</title>
  9.    <link rel="canonical" href="https://blog-9630758412.mit-edu.top/post/9630758412">
  10.    <link rel="stylesheet" href="https://fonts.googleapis.com/css2?family=Poppins:wght@400;700&display=swap">
  11.    <link rel="stylesheet" href="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/css/style.css">
  12.    <script src="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/js/lazysizes.min.js" async></script>
  13.    <link rel="shortcut icon" href="/favicon.ico">
  14.    <!-- Open Graph Metadata -->
  15.    <meta property="og:type" content="article" />
  16.    <meta property="og:title" content="Data-Driven Insights into Player Churn in Freemium Game Models" />
  17.    <meta property="og:description" content="Data-Driven Insights into Player Churn in Freemium Game Models #922337408791 (2025-01-31)" />
  18.    <meta property="og:url" content="https://blog-9630758412.mit-edu.top/post/9630758412" />
  19.    <meta property="og:site_name" content="mit-edu.top" />
  20.    <meta property="og:image" content="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/images/post/17.jpg" />
  21.    <meta property="og:article:published_time" content="2025-01-31T09:02:06Z" />
  22.    <meta property="og:article:author" content="Dr. Anthony Edwards" />
  23.    <meta property="og:article:section" content="mit-edu.top" />
  24.    <meta property="og:article:tag" content="Games, Mobile Games, Video Games" />
  25.    <!-- Schema.org -->
  26.    <script type="application/ld+json">{
  27.            "@context": "https://schema.org",
  28.            "@type": "ScholarlyArticle",
  29.            "headline": "Data-Driven Insights into Player Churn in Freemium Game Models #922337408791 (2025-01-31)",
  30.            "author": {
  31.                "@type": "Person",
  32.                "name": "Dr. Anthony Edwards",
  33.                "affiliation": {
  34.                    "@type": "Organization",
  35.                    "name": "mit-edu.top"
  36.                },
  37.                "url": "https://blog-9630758412.mit-edu.top/post/9630758412"
  38.            },
  39.            "datePublished": "2025-01-31T09:02:06Z",
  40.            "image": "https://x.mit-edu.top/static/images/post/17.jpg",
  41.            "journal": {
  42.                "@type": "Periodical",
  43.                "name": "mit-edu.top",
  44.                "issn": "10.1069/922337408791"
  45.            },
  46.            "publisher": {
  47.                "@type": "Organization",
  48.                "name": "mit-edu.top",
  49.                "url": "https://blog-9630758412.mit-edu.top"
  50.            },
  51.            "doi": "922337408791",
  52.            "abstract": "Data-Driven Insights into Player Churn in Freemium Game Models #922337408791 (2025-01-31)",
  53.            "citation": {
  54.                "@type": "CreativeWork",
  55.                "name": "Data-Driven Insights into Player Churn in Freemium Game Models",
  56.                "author": "Dr. Anthony Edwards",
  57.                "datePublished": "2025-01-31T09:02:06Z",
  58.                "url": "https://blog-9630758412.mit-edu.top/post/9630758412"
  59.            }
  60.        }
  61.    </script>
  62. </head>
  63.  
  64. <body>
  65.    <div class="site-mobile-menu site-navbar-target">
  66.        <div class="site-mobile-menu-header">
  67.            <div class="site-mobile-menu-close">
  68.                <span class="icofont-close js-menu-toggle"></span>
  69.            </div>
  70.        </div>
  71.        <div class="site-mobile-menu-body"></div>
  72.    </div>
  73.    <nav class="site-nav">
  74.        <div class="container">
  75.            <div class="site-navigation">
  76.                <div class="row">
  77.                    <div class="col-md-6 text-center order-1 order-md-2 mb-3 mb-md-0">
  78.                        <a href="https://blog-9630758412.mit-edu.top" class="logo m-0 text-uppercase">mit-edu.top</a>
  79.                    </div>
  80.                    <div class="col-md-3 order-3 order-md-1">
  81.                    </div>
  82.                </div>
  83.            </div>
  84.        </div>
  85.    </nav>
  86.    <div class="section post-section pt-5">
  87.        <div class="container">
  88.            <div class="row justify-content-center">
  89.                <div class="col-lg-8">
  90.                    <div class="text-center">
  91.                        <img src="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/images/user/12.jpg" alt="Data-Driven Insights into Player Churn in Freemium Game Models" title="Data-Driven Insights into Player Churn in Freemium Game Models" class="author-pic img-fluid rounded-circle mx-auto">
  92.                    </div>
  93.                    <span class="d-block text-center">Anthony Edwards</span>
  94.                    <span class="date d-block text-center small text-uppercase text-black-50 mb-5">2025-01-31</span>
  95.                    <h2 class="heading text-center">Data-Driven Insights into Player Churn in Freemium Game Models</h2>
  96.                    <p class="lead mb-4 text-center">Thanks to Anthony Edwards for contributing the article "Data-Driven Insights into Player Churn in Freemium Game Models".
  97.                    </p>
  98.                    <img src="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/images/post/17.jpg" alt="Data-Driven Insights into Player Churn in Freemium Game Models" title="Data-Driven Insights into Player Churn in Freemium Game Models" class="img-fluid rounded mb-4 lazyload">
  99.                    <p>This paper investigates the use of artificial intelligence (AI) for dynamic content generation in mobile games, focusing on how procedural content creation (PCC) techniques enable developers to create expansive, personalized game worlds that evolve based on player actions. The study explores the algorithms and methodologies used in PCC, such as procedural terrain generation, dynamic narrative structures, and adaptive enemy behavior, and how they enhance player experience by providing infinite variability. Drawing on computer science, game design, and machine learning, the paper examines the potential of AI-driven content generation to create more engaging and replayable mobile games, while considering the challenges of maintaining balance, coherence, and quality in procedurally generated content.</p>
  100. <p>Virtual reality gaming has unlocked a new dimension of immersion, transporting players into fantastical realms where they can interact with virtual environments and characters in ways previously unimaginable. The sensory richness of VR experiences, coupled with intuitive motion controls, has redefined how players engage with games, blurring the boundaries between the digital realm and the physical world.</p>
  101. <p>The siren song of RPGs beckons with its immersive narratives, drawing players into worlds so vividly crafted that the boundaries between reality and fantasy blur, leaving gamers spellbound in their pixelated destinies. From epic tales of heroism and adventure to nuanced character-driven dramas, RPGs offer a storytelling experience unlike any other, allowing players to become the protagonists of their own epic sagas. The freedom to make choices, shape the narrative, and explore vast, richly detailed worlds sparks the imagination and fosters a deep emotional connection with the virtual realms they inhabit.</p>
  102. <p>This research investigates the environmental footprint of mobile gaming, including energy consumption, electronic waste, and resource usage. It proposes sustainable practices for game development and consumption.This study examines how mobile gaming serves as a platform for social interaction, allowing players to form and maintain relationships. It explores the dynamics of online communities and the social benefits of gaming.</p>
  103. <p>Indie game developers play a vital role in shaping the diverse landscape of gaming, bringing fresh perspectives, innovative gameplay mechanics, and compelling narratives to the forefront. Their creative freedom and entrepreneurial spirit fuel a culture of experimentation and discovery, driving the industry forward with bold ideas and unique gaming experiences that captivate players' imaginations.</p>
  104.  
  105.                    <p>
  106.                    <a href="/redirect/?url=https://blog-9630758412.mit-edu.top/post/9630758412" target="_blank" class="custom-link">Link</a>
  107.                    </p>
  108.                    <p><a href="https://www.linegames.org/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  109. <a href="https://www.iliiili.com/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  110. <a href="https://www.digwow.net/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  111. <a href="https://www.free-giftcodes.com/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  112. <a href="https://www.gifthub.com.ru/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  113. <a href="https://823408683285-edu.iliiili.com/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  114. <a href="https://779423886972-edu.digwow.net/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  115. <a href="https://227040132473-edu.free-giftcodes.com/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  116. <a href="https://341760237279-edu.gifthub.com.ru/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  117. <a href="https://567254486181-gov.iliiili.com/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  118. <a href="https://195442786953-gov.digwow.net/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  119. <a href="https://976604550286-gov.free-giftcodes.com/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  120. <a href="https://724342552006-gov.gifthub.com.ru/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  121. <a href="https://374060358918-gov-edu.iliiili.com/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  122. <a href="https://474492074518-gov-edu.digwow.net/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  123. <a href="https://764074702108-gov-edu.free-giftcodes.com/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  124. <a href="https://244036883223-gov-edu.gifthub.com.ru/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  125. <a href="https://530981858365-edu.iliiili.com/?url=https://blog-9630758412.mit-edu.top/post/9630758412" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  126. <a href="https://735056870384-edu.digwow.net/?url=https://blog-9630758412.mit-edu.top/post/9630758412" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  127. <a href="https://972204657646-edu.free-giftcodes.com/?url=https://blog-9630758412.mit-edu.top/post/9630758412" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  128. <a href="https://832668141747-edu.gifthub.com.ru/?url=https://blog-9630758412.mit-edu.top/post/9630758412" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  129. <a href="https://334463850180-gov.iliiili.com/?url=https://blog-9630758412.mit-edu.top/post/9630758412" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  130. <a href="https://655419003269-gov.digwow.net/?url=https://blog-9630758412.mit-edu.top/post/9630758412" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  131. <a href="https://083258991437-gov.free-giftcodes.com/?url=https://blog-9630758412.mit-edu.top/post/9630758412" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  132. <a href="https://723732797249-gov.gifthub.com.ru/?url=https://blog-9630758412.mit-edu.top/post/9630758412" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  133. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?249666574900&amp;url=https://blog-9630758412.mit-edu.top/post/9630758412" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  134. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?799943715199&amp;url=https://naver799943715199-edu.digwow.net" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  135. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?379103138195&amp;url=https://naver379103138195-edu.iliiili.com" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  136. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?742142222117&amp;url=https://naver742142222117-edu.1717173.xyz" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  137. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?589198036046&amp;url=https://naver589198036046-edu.gifthub.com.ru" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  138. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?469278743068&amp;url=https://naver469278743068-gov.digwow.net" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  139. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?380501269179&amp;url=https://naver380501269179-gov.iliiili.com" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  140. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?082687333250&amp;url=https://naver082687333250-gov.1717173.xyz" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  141. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?135542371332&amp;url=https://naver135542371332-gov.gifthub.com.ru" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  142. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?568485383652&amp;url=https://naver568485383652-gov-edu.digwow.net" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  143. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?385611734389&amp;url=https://naver385611734389-gov-edu.iliiili.com" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  144. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?516750906754&amp;url=https://naver516750906754-gov-edu.1717173.xyz" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  145. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?393659988459&amp;url=https://naver393659988459-gov-edu.gifthub.com.ru" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  146. <a href="https://blog-522051912688.gifthub.news/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  147. <a href="https://blog-678254783158.jp-edu.sbs/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  148. <a href="https://blog-046991854150.kr-edu.sbs/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  149. <a href="https://blog-251520387213.krlinkedin.sbs/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  150. <a href="https://blog-691006810509.mit-edu.sbs/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  151. <a href="https://blog-794100136388.mit-edu.buzz/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  152. <a href="https://blog-327159518618.mit-edu.tech/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  153. <a href="https://blog-200350330841.mit-edu.site/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  154. <a href="https://blog-964603445260.mit-edu.top/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  155. <a href="https://blog-112974805841.usa-gov.top/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  156. <a href="https://research-984968065525.mit-edu.pp.ua/?url=https://blog-9630758412.mit-edu.top/post/9630758412" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  157. <a href="https://research-879495517704.harvard-edu.pp.ua/?url=https://blog-9630758412.mit-edu.top/post/9630758412" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  158. <a href="https://research-295770968365.stanford-edu.pp.ua/?url=https://blog-9630758412.mit-edu.top/post/9630758412" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  159. <a href="https://research-271723301350.cambridge-edu.pp.ua/?url=https://blog-9630758412.mit-edu.top/post/9630758412" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  160. <a href="https://research-901682101689.berkeley-edu.pp.ua/?url=https://blog-9630758412.mit-edu.top/post/9630758412" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  161. <a href="https://research-786512139212.oxford-edu.pp.ua/?url=https://blog-9630758412.mit-edu.top/post/9630758412" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  162. <a href="https://research-642788878036-edu.wwv.pp.ua/?url=https://blog-9630758412.mit-edu.top/post/9630758412" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  163. <a href="https://research-247416394045-edu.sean.pp.ua/?url=https://blog-9630758412.mit-edu.top/post/9630758412" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  164. <a href="https://research-259281456724-edu.line.pp.ua/?url=https://blog-9630758412.mit-edu.top/post/9630758412" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  165. </p>
  166.                    <div class="row mt-5 pt-5 border-top">
  167.                    </div>
  168.                </div>
  169.            </div>
  170.        </div>
  171.    </div>
  172.    <div class="section pb-0">
  173.        <div class="container">
  174.            <div class="row">
  175.                <div class="col-lg-12">
  176.                    <h2 class="heading">Related</h2>
  177.                </div>
  178.            </div>
  179.            <div class="row justify-content-center">
  180.                <div class="col-lg-12">
  181.                    <div class="post-entry d-md-flex small-horizontal mb-5">
  182.                        <div class="me-md-5 thumbnail mb-3 mb-md-0">
  183.                            <a href="https://blog-9630758412.mit-edu.top/post/5462197038">
  184.                            <img src="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/images/post/17.jpg" alt="Adversarial Attack Detection in Mobile Game AI Algorithms" title="Adversarial Attack Detection in Mobile Game AI Algorithms" class="img-fluid lazyload">
  185.                            </a>
  186.                        </div>
  187.                        <div class="content">
  188.                            <div class="post-meta mb-3">
  189.                                <a href="https://blog-5462197038.mit-edu.top/post/5462197038/" target="_blank">
  190.                                <span class="date">2025-01-31</span>
  191.                                </a>
  192.                            </div>
  193.                            <h2 class="heading"><a href="https://blog-9630758412.mit-edu.top/post/5462197038">Adversarial Attack Detection in Mobile Game AI Algorithms</a></h2>
  194.                            <p class="info">Gaming culture has evolved into a vibrant and interconnected community where players from diverse backgrounds and cultures converge. They share strategies, forge lasting alliances, and engage in friendly competition, turning virtual friendships into real-world connections that span continents. Beyond gaming itself, this global community often rallies around charitable causes, organizing fundraising events, and using their collective influence for social good, showcasing the positive impact of gaming on society.</p>
  195.                            <a href="https://blog-9630758412.mit-edu.top/post/5462197038" class="post-author d-flex align-items-center">
  196.                                <div class="author-pic">
  197.                                    <img src="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/images/user/12.jpg" alt="Adversarial Attack Detection in Mobile Game AI Algorithms" title="Adversarial Attack Detection in Mobile Game AI Algorithms" class="lazyload">
  198.                                </div>
  199.                                <div class="text">
  200.                                    <strong>Brandon Barnes</strong>
  201.                                    <span>2025-01-31 published post</span>
  202.                                </div>
  203.                            </a>
  204.                        </div>
  205.                    </div>
  206.                </div>
  207.                <div class="col-lg-12">
  208.                    <div class="post-entry d-md-flex small-horizontal mb-5">
  209.                        <div class="me-md-5 thumbnail mb-3 mb-md-0">
  210.                            <a href="https://blog-9630758412.mit-edu.top/post/5387419620">
  211.                            <img src="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/images/post/11.jpg" alt="Reinforcement Learning with Sparse Rewards for Procedural Game Content Generation" title="Reinforcement Learning with Sparse Rewards for Procedural Game Content Generation" class="img-fluid lazyload">
  212.                            </a>
  213.                        </div>
  214.                        <div class="content">
  215.                            <div class="post-meta mb-3">
  216.                                <a href="https://blog-5387419620.mit-edu.top/post/5387419620/" target="_blank">
  217.                                <span class="date">2025-01-31</span>
  218.                                </a>
  219.                            </div>
  220.                            <h2 class="heading"><a href="https://blog-9630758412.mit-edu.top/post/5387419620">Reinforcement Learning with Sparse Rewards for Procedural Game Content Generation</a></h2>
  221.                            <p class="info">This study delves into the various strategies that mobile game developers use to maximize user retention, including personalized content, rewards systems, and social integration. It explores how data analytics are employed to track player behavior, predict churn, and optimize engagement strategies. The research also discusses the ethical concerns related to user tracking and retention tactics, proposing frameworks for responsible data use.</p>
  222.                            <a href="https://blog-9630758412.mit-edu.top/post/5387419620" class="post-author d-flex align-items-center">
  223.                                <div class="author-pic">
  224.                                    <img src="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/images/user/10.jpg" alt="Reinforcement Learning with Sparse Rewards for Procedural Game Content Generation" title="Reinforcement Learning with Sparse Rewards for Procedural Game Content Generation" class="lazyload">
  225.                                </div>
  226.                                <div class="text">
  227.                                    <strong>Harold Matthews</strong>
  228.                                    <span>2025-01-31 published post</span>
  229.                                </div>
  230.                            </a>
  231.                        </div>
  232.                    </div>
  233.                </div>
  234.                <div class="col-lg-12">
  235.                    <div class="post-entry d-md-flex small-horizontal mb-5">
  236.                        <div class="me-md-5 thumbnail mb-3 mb-md-0">
  237.                            <a href="https://blog-9630758412.mit-edu.top/post/7042638951">
  238.                            <img src="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/images/post/12.jpg" alt="The Long-Term Effects of Achievement Systems on Player Motivation" title="The Long-Term Effects of Achievement Systems on Player Motivation" class="img-fluid lazyload">
  239.                            </a>
  240.                        </div>
  241.                        <div class="content">
  242.                            <div class="post-meta mb-3">
  243.                                <a href="https://blog-7042638951.mit-edu.top/post/7042638951/" target="_blank">
  244.                                <span class="date">2025-01-31</span>
  245.                                </a>
  246.                            </div>
  247.                            <h2 class="heading"><a href="https://blog-9630758412.mit-edu.top/post/7042638951">The Long-Term Effects of Achievement Systems on Player Motivation</a></h2>
  248.                            <p class="info">Puzzles, as enigmatic as they are rewarding, challenge players' intellect and wit, their solutions often hidden in plain sight yet requiring a discerning eye and a strategic mind to unravel their secrets and claim the coveted rewards. Whether deciphering cryptic clues, manipulating intricate mechanisms, or solving complex riddles, the puzzle-solving aspect of gaming exercises the brain and encourages creative problem-solving skills. The satisfaction of finally cracking a difficult puzzle after careful analysis and experimentation is a testament to the mental agility and perseverance of gamers, rewarding them with a sense of accomplishment and progression.</p>
  249.                            <a href="https://blog-9630758412.mit-edu.top/post/7042638951" class="post-author d-flex align-items-center">
  250.                                <div class="author-pic">
  251.                                    <img src="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/images/user/8.jpg" alt="The Long-Term Effects of Achievement Systems on Player Motivation" title="The Long-Term Effects of Achievement Systems on Player Motivation" class="lazyload">
  252.                                </div>
  253.                                <div class="text">
  254.                                    <strong>Michael Davis</strong>
  255.                                    <span>2025-01-31 published post</span>
  256.                                </div>
  257.                            </a>
  258.                        </div>
  259.                    </div>
  260.                </div>
  261.            </div>
  262.        </div>
  263.    </div>
  264.    <div class="py-5 bg-light mx-md-3 sec-subscribe">
  265.        <div class="container">
  266.            <div class="row">
  267.                <div class="col-lg-12">
  268.                    <h2 class="h4 fw-bold">Subscribe to newsletter</h2>
  269.                </div>
  270.            </div>
  271.            <form class="row">
  272.                <div class="col-md-8">
  273.                    <div class="mb-3 mb-md-0">
  274.                        <input type="email" class="form-control" placeholder="Enter your email">
  275.                    </div>
  276.                </div>
  277.                <div class="col-md-4 d-grid">
  278.                    <input type="submit" class="btn btn-primary" value="Subscribe">
  279.                </div>
  280.            </form>
  281.        </div>
  282.    </div>
  283.    <div class="site-footer">
  284.        <div class="container">
  285.            <div class="row justify-content-center copyright">
  286.                <div class="col-lg-7 text-center">
  287.                    <div class="widget">
  288.                        <p>Copyright &copy;
  289.                            <script>document.write(new Date().getFullYear());</script> All rights reserved.
  290.                        </p>
  291. <p>
  292.    < Top VPS Hosting Choice ><br>
  293.    <a href="https://evolution-host.com?ref=DQgZ6P" target="_blank">
  294.        <img src="https://x.mit-edu.top/static/images/evolution-host.png" alt="Evolution Host" title="Evolution Host" class="evhost lazyload">
  295.    </a>
  296. </p>
  297.                    </div>
  298.                </div>
  299.            </div>
  300.        </div>
  301.    </div>
  302. </body>
  303.  
  304. </html>
Copyright © 2002-9 Sam Ruby, Mark Pilgrim, Joseph Walton, and Phil Ringnalda