It looks like this is a web page, not a feed. I looked for a feed associated with this page, but couldn't find one. Please enter the address of your feed to validate.

Source: https://research-747993.gifthub.news/post/8236740915

  1. <!doctype html>
  2. <html xmlns="http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml" xml:lang="en" lang="en" prefix="og: http://ogp.me/ns#">
  3.  
  4.  <head>
  5.    <meta charset="utf-8">
  6.    <meta name="applicable-device" content="pc,mobile">
  7.    <meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width, initial-scale=1">
  8.    <title>The Paradox of Scarcity: Balancing Supply and Demand in Virtual Goods Markets #155943839936 (2025-02-01)</title>
  9.    <link rel="canonical" href="https://research-747993.gifthub.news/post/8236740915">
  10.    <link rel="stylesheet" href="https://fonts.googleapis.com/css2?family=Poppins:wght@400;700&display=swap">
  11.    <link rel="stylesheet" href="https://x.gifthub.news/static/css/style.css">
  12.    <script src="https://x.gifthub.news/static/js/lazysizes.min.js" async></script>
  13.    <link rel="shortcut icon" href="/favicon.ico">
  14.    <!-- Open Graph Metadata -->
  15.    <meta property="og:type" content="article" />
  16.    <meta property="og:title" content="The Paradox of Scarcity: Balancing Supply and Demand in Virtual Goods Markets" />
  17.    <meta property="og:description" content="The Paradox of Scarcity: Balancing Supply and Demand in Virtual Goods Markets #155943839936 (2025-02-01)" />
  18.    <meta property="og:url" content="https://research-747993.gifthub.news/post/8236740915" />
  19.    <meta property="og:site_name" content="gifthub.news" />
  20.    <meta property="og:image" content="https://x.gifthub.news/static/images/post/9.jpg" />
  21.    <meta property="og:article:published_time" content="2025-02-01T06:56:37Z" />
  22.    <meta property="og:article:author" content="Dr. Cynthia Bailey" />
  23.    <meta property="og:article:section" content="gifthub.news" />
  24.    <meta property="og:article:tag" content="Games, Mobile Games, Video Games" />
  25.    <!-- Schema.org -->
  26.    <script type="application/ld+json">{
  27.            "@context": "https://schema.org",
  28.            "@type": "ScholarlyArticle",
  29.            "headline": "The Paradox of Scarcity: Balancing Supply and Demand in Virtual Goods Markets #155943839936 (2025-02-01)",
  30.            "author": {
  31.                "@type": "Person",
  32.                "name": "Dr. Cynthia Bailey",
  33.                "affiliation": {
  34.                    "@type": "Organization",
  35.                    "name": "gifthub.news"
  36.                },
  37.                "url": "https://research-747993.gifthub.news/post/8236740915"
  38.            },
  39.            "datePublished": "2025-02-01T06:56:37Z",
  40.            "image": "https://x.gifthub.news/static/images/post/9.jpg",
  41.            "journal": {
  42.                "@type": "Periodical",
  43.                "name": "gifthub.news",
  44.                "issn": "10.1069/155943839936"
  45.            },
  46.            "publisher": {
  47.                "@type": "Organization",
  48.                "name": "gifthub.news",
  49.                "url": "https://research-747993.gifthub.news"
  50.            },
  51.            "doi": "155943839936",
  52.            "abstract": "The Paradox of Scarcity: Balancing Supply and Demand in Virtual Goods Markets #155943839936 (2025-02-01)",
  53.            "citation": {
  54.                "@type": "CreativeWork",
  55.                "name": "The Paradox of Scarcity: Balancing Supply and Demand in Virtual Goods Markets",
  56.                "author": "Dr. Cynthia Bailey",
  57.                "datePublished": "2025-02-01T06:56:37Z",
  58.                "url": "https://research-747993.gifthub.news/post/8236740915"
  59.            }
  60.        }
  61.    </script>
  62. </head>
  63.  
  64. <body>
  65.    <div class="site-mobile-menu site-navbar-target">
  66.        <div class="site-mobile-menu-header">
  67.            <div class="site-mobile-menu-close">
  68.                <span class="icofont-close js-menu-toggle"></span>
  69.            </div>
  70.        </div>
  71.        <div class="site-mobile-menu-body"></div>
  72.    </div>
  73.    <nav class="site-nav">
  74.        <div class="container">
  75.            <div class="site-navigation">
  76.                <div class="row">
  77.                    <div class="col-md-6 text-center order-1 order-md-2 mb-3 mb-md-0">
  78.                        <a href="https://research-747993.gifthub.news" class="logo m-0 text-uppercase">gifthub.news</a>
  79.                    </div>
  80.                    <div class="col-md-3 order-3 order-md-1">
  81.                    </div>
  82.                </div>
  83.            </div>
  84.        </div>
  85.    </nav>
  86.    <div class="section post-section pt-5">
  87.        <div class="container">
  88.            <div class="row justify-content-center">
  89.                <div class="col-lg-8">
  90.                    <div class="text-center">
  91.                        <img src="https://x.gifthub.news/static/images/user/13.jpg" alt="The Paradox of Scarcity: Balancing Supply and Demand in Virtual Goods Markets" title="The Paradox of Scarcity: Balancing Supply and Demand in Virtual Goods Markets" class="author-pic img-fluid rounded-circle mx-auto">
  92.                    </div>
  93.                    <span class="d-block text-center">Cynthia Bailey</span>
  94.                    <span class="date d-block text-center small text-uppercase text-black-50 mb-5">2025-02-01</span>
  95.                    <h2 class="heading text-center">The Paradox of Scarcity: Balancing Supply and Demand in Virtual Goods Markets</h2>
  96.                    <p class="lead mb-4 text-center">Thanks to Cynthia Bailey for contributing the article "The Paradox of Scarcity: Balancing Supply and Demand in Virtual Goods Markets".
  97.                    </p>
  98.                    <img src="https://x.gifthub.news/static/images/post/9.jpg" alt="The Paradox of Scarcity: Balancing Supply and Demand in Virtual Goods Markets" title="The Paradox of Scarcity: Balancing Supply and Demand in Virtual Goods Markets" class="img-fluid rounded mb-4 lazyload">
  99.                    <p>Gaming communities thrive in digital spaces, bustling forums, social media hubs, and streaming platforms where players converge to share strategies, discuss game lore, showcase fan art, and forge connections with fellow enthusiasts. These vibrant communities serve as hubs of creativity, camaraderie, and collective celebration of all things gaming-related.</p>
  100. <p>This paper investigates how different motivational theories, such as self-determination theory (SDT) and the theory of planned behavior (TPB), are applied to mobile health games that aim to promote positive behavioral changes in health-related practices. The study compares various mobile health games and their design elements, including rewards, goal-setting, and social support mechanisms, to evaluate how these elements align with motivational frameworks and influence long-term health behavior change. The paper provides recommendations for designers on how to integrate motivational theory into mobile health games to maximize user engagement, retention, and sustained behavioral modification.</p>
  101. <p>From the nostalgic allure of retro classics to the cutting-edge simulations of modern gaming, the evolution of this immersive medium mirrors humanity's insatiable thirst for innovation, escapism, and boundless exploration. The rich tapestry of gaming history is woven with iconic titles that have left an indelible mark on pop culture and inspired generations of players. As technology advances and artistic vision continues to push the boundaries of what's possible, the gaming landscape evolves, offering new experiences, genres, and innovations that captivate and enthrall players worldwide.</p>
  102. <p>This research investigates the ethical, psychological, and economic impacts of virtual item purchases in free-to-play mobile games. The study explores how microtransactions and virtual goods, such as skins, power-ups, and loot boxes, influence player behavior, spending habits, and overall satisfaction. Drawing on consumer behavior theory, economic models, and psychological studies of behavior change, the paper examines the role of virtual goods in creating addictive spending patterns, particularly among vulnerable populations such as minors or players with compulsive tendencies. The research also discusses the ethical implications of monetizing gameplay through virtual goods and provides recommendations for developers to create fairer and more transparent in-game purchase systems.</p>
  103. <p>Gaming events and conventions serve as epicenters of excitement and celebration, where developers unveil new titles, showcase cutting-edge technology, host competitive tournaments, and connect with fans face-to-face. Events like E3, Gamescom, and PAX are not just gatherings but cultural phenomena that unite gaming enthusiasts in shared anticipation, excitement, and camaraderie.</p>
  104.  
  105.                    <p>
  106.                    <a href="/redirect/?url=https://research-747993.gifthub.news/post/8236740915" target="_blank" class="custom-link">Link</a>
  107.                    </p>
  108.                    <p><a href="https://www.linegames.org/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  109. <a href="https://www.iliiili.com/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  110. <a href="https://www.digwow.net/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  111. <a href="https://www.free-giftcodes.com/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  112. <a href="https://www.gifthub.com.ru/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  113. <a href="https://656140450997-edu.iliiili.com/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  114. <a href="https://114861179493-edu.digwow.net/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  115. <a href="https://565216782397-edu.free-giftcodes.com/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  116. <a href="https://442442163649-edu.gifthub.com.ru/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  117. <a href="https://867807163785-gov.iliiili.com/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  118. <a href="https://454694338683-gov.digwow.net/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  119. <a href="https://809163140920-gov.free-giftcodes.com/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  120. <a href="https://646015561920-gov.gifthub.com.ru/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  121. <a href="https://364232623539-gov-edu.iliiili.com/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  122. <a href="https://954957011713-gov-edu.digwow.net/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  123. <a href="https://279472518942-gov-edu.free-giftcodes.com/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  124. <a href="https://204558553948-gov-edu.gifthub.com.ru/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  125. <a href="https://640722159096-edu.iliiili.com/?url=https://research-747993.gifthub.news/post/8236740915" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  126. <a href="https://258142372828-edu.digwow.net/?url=https://research-747993.gifthub.news/post/8236740915" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  127. <a href="https://673978832914-edu.free-giftcodes.com/?url=https://research-747993.gifthub.news/post/8236740915" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  128. <a href="https://120139764689-edu.gifthub.com.ru/?url=https://research-747993.gifthub.news/post/8236740915" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  129. <a href="https://826109966364-gov.iliiili.com/?url=https://research-747993.gifthub.news/post/8236740915" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  130. <a href="https://157449962976-gov.digwow.net/?url=https://research-747993.gifthub.news/post/8236740915" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  131. <a href="https://842311393914-gov.free-giftcodes.com/?url=https://research-747993.gifthub.news/post/8236740915" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  132. <a href="https://811547953797-gov.gifthub.com.ru/?url=https://research-747993.gifthub.news/post/8236740915" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  133. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?693980575806&amp;url=https://research-747993.gifthub.news/post/8236740915" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  134. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?036438829973&amp;url=https://naver036438829973-edu.digwow.net" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  135. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?779048817116&amp;url=https://naver779048817116-edu.iliiili.com" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  136. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?273754458101&amp;url=https://naver273754458101-edu.1717173.xyz" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  137. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?983881269164&amp;url=https://naver983881269164-edu.gifthub.com.ru" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  138. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?046867484760&amp;url=https://naver046867484760-gov.digwow.net" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  139. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?116036124513&amp;url=https://naver116036124513-gov.iliiili.com" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  140. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?739646050636&amp;url=https://naver739646050636-gov.1717173.xyz" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  141. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?475852873476&amp;url=https://naver475852873476-gov.gifthub.com.ru" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  142. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?089540914889&amp;url=https://naver089540914889-gov-edu.digwow.net" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  143. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?584557295870&amp;url=https://naver584557295870-gov-edu.iliiili.com" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  144. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?067314013977&amp;url=https://naver067314013977-gov-edu.1717173.xyz" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  145. <a href="https://link.naver.com/bridge?069557405961&amp;url=https://naver069557405961-gov-edu.gifthub.com.ru" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  146. <a href="https://blog-790278375016.gifthub.news/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  147. <a href="https://blog-518815622578.jp-edu.sbs/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  148. <a href="https://blog-229815085113.kr-edu.sbs/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  149. <a href="https://blog-941552104996.krlinkedin.sbs/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  150. <a href="https://blog-458715547429.mit-edu.sbs/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  151. <a href="https://blog-038549934099.mit-edu.buzz/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  152. <a href="https://blog-300790446217.mit-edu.tech/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  153. <a href="https://blog-871614527481.mit-edu.site/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  154. <a href="https://blog-375874805985.mit-edu.top/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  155. <a href="https://blog-939551248400.usa-gov.top/" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  156. <a href="https://research-953601839426.mit-edu.pp.ua/?url=https://research-747993.gifthub.news/post/8236740915" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  157. <a href="https://research-917406999955.harvard-edu.pp.ua/?url=https://research-747993.gifthub.news/post/8236740915" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  158. <a href="https://research-189020116486.stanford-edu.pp.ua/?url=https://research-747993.gifthub.news/post/8236740915" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  159. <a href="https://research-670522213064.cambridge-edu.pp.ua/?url=https://research-747993.gifthub.news/post/8236740915" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  160. <a href="https://research-763668276289.berkeley-edu.pp.ua/?url=https://research-747993.gifthub.news/post/8236740915" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  161. <a href="https://research-291940508550.oxford-edu.pp.ua/?url=https://research-747993.gifthub.news/post/8236740915" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  162. <a href="https://research-872189555922-edu.wwv.pp.ua/?url=https://research-747993.gifthub.news/post/8236740915" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  163. <a href="https://research-840578408692-edu.sean.pp.ua/?url=https://research-747993.gifthub.news/post/8236740915" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  164. <a href="https://research-643408586704-edu.line.pp.ua/?url=https://research-747993.gifthub.news/post/8236740915" target="_blank" class="custom-link">External link</a>
  165. </p>
  166.                    <div class="row mt-5 pt-5 border-top">
  167.                    </div>
  168.                </div>
  169.            </div>
  170.        </div>
  171.    </div>
  172.    <div class="section pb-0">
  173.        <div class="container">
  174.            <div class="row">
  175.                <div class="col-lg-12">
  176.                    <h2 class="heading">Related</h2>
  177.                </div>
  178.            </div>
  179.            <div class="row justify-content-center">
  180.                <div class="col-lg-12">
  181.                    <div class="post-entry d-md-flex small-horizontal mb-5">
  182.                        <div class="me-md-5 thumbnail mb-3 mb-md-0">
  183.                            <a href="https://research-747993.gifthub.news/post/4567839012">
  184.                            <img src="https://x.gifthub.news/static/images/post/9.jpg" alt="Microeconomic Simulations of Player Choices in Virtual Economies" title="Microeconomic Simulations of Player Choices in Virtual Economies" class="img-fluid lazyload">
  185.                            </a>
  186.                        </div>
  187.                        <div class="content">
  188.                            <div class="post-meta mb-3">
  189.                                <a href="https://blog-4567839012.gifthub.news/post/4567839012/" target="_blank">
  190.                                <span class="date">2025-02-01</span>
  191.                                </a>
  192.                            </div>
  193.                            <h2 class="heading"><a href="https://research-747993.gifthub.news/post/4567839012">Microeconomic Simulations of Player Choices in Virtual Economies</a></h2>
  194.                            <p class="info">This paper investigates the ethical implications of digital addiction in mobile games, specifically focusing on the role of game design in preventing compulsive play and overuse. The research explores how game mechanics such as reward systems, social comparison, and time-limited events may contribute to addictive behavior, particularly in vulnerable populations. Drawing on behavioral addiction theories, the study examines how developers can design games that are both engaging and ethical by avoiding exploitative practices while promoting healthy gaming habits. The paper also discusses strategies for mitigating the negative impacts of digital addiction, such as incorporating breaks, time limits, and player welfare features, to reduce the risk of game-related compulsive behavior.</p>
  195.                            <a href="https://research-747993.gifthub.news/post/4567839012" class="post-author d-flex align-items-center">
  196.                                <div class="author-pic">
  197.                                    <img src="https://x.gifthub.news/static/images/user/13.jpg" alt="Microeconomic Simulations of Player Choices in Virtual Economies" title="Microeconomic Simulations of Player Choices in Virtual Economies" class="lazyload">
  198.                                </div>
  199.                                <div class="text">
  200.                                    <strong>Sharon Cox</strong>
  201.                                    <span>2025-02-01 published post</span>
  202.                                </div>
  203.                            </a>
  204.                        </div>
  205.                    </div>
  206.                </div>
  207.                <div class="col-lg-12">
  208.                    <div class="post-entry d-md-flex small-horizontal mb-5">
  209.                        <div class="me-md-5 thumbnail mb-3 mb-md-0">
  210.                            <a href="https://research-747993.gifthub.news/post/5812063749">
  211.                            <img src="https://x.gifthub.news/static/images/post/15.jpg" alt="Legal Challenges in Cross-Border Virtual Currency Transactions" title="Legal Challenges in Cross-Border Virtual Currency Transactions" class="img-fluid lazyload">
  212.                            </a>
  213.                        </div>
  214.                        <div class="content">
  215.                            <div class="post-meta mb-3">
  216.                                <a href="https://blog-5812063749.gifthub.news/post/5812063749/" target="_blank">
  217.                                <span class="date">2025-02-01</span>
  218.                                </a>
  219.                            </div>
  220.                            <h2 class="heading"><a href="https://research-747993.gifthub.news/post/5812063749">Legal Challenges in Cross-Border Virtual Currency Transactions</a></h2>
  221.                            <p class="info">This study examines how engaging with mobile games affects attention span and cognitive control processes. It investigates both the potential benefits, such as improved focus, and the risks, such as attention deficits.This paper analyzes the development and diversification of mobile game genres over time, highlighting key trends and innovative game mechanics. It discusses how these changes reflect technological advancements and shifting player preferences.</p>
  222.                            <a href="https://research-747993.gifthub.news/post/5812063749" class="post-author d-flex align-items-center">
  223.                                <div class="author-pic">
  224.                                    <img src="https://x.gifthub.news/static/images/user/10.jpg" alt="Legal Challenges in Cross-Border Virtual Currency Transactions" title="Legal Challenges in Cross-Border Virtual Currency Transactions" class="lazyload">
  225.                                </div>
  226.                                <div class="text">
  227.                                    <strong>Anna Ross</strong>
  228.                                    <span>2025-02-01 published post</span>
  229.                                </div>
  230.                            </a>
  231.                        </div>
  232.                    </div>
  233.                </div>
  234.                <div class="col-lg-12">
  235.                    <div class="post-entry d-md-flex small-horizontal mb-5">
  236.                        <div class="me-md-5 thumbnail mb-3 mb-md-0">
  237.                            <a href="https://research-747993.gifthub.news/post/8026947315">
  238.                            <img src="https://x.gifthub.news/static/images/post/15.jpg" alt="Impact of Multiplayer Educational Games on Collaborative Problem-Solving Skills" title="Impact of Multiplayer Educational Games on Collaborative Problem-Solving Skills" class="img-fluid lazyload">
  239.                            </a>
  240.                        </div>
  241.                        <div class="content">
  242.                            <div class="post-meta mb-3">
  243.                                <a href="https://blog-8026947315.gifthub.news/post/8026947315/" target="_blank">
  244.                                <span class="date">2025-02-01</span>
  245.                                </a>
  246.                            </div>
  247.                            <h2 class="heading"><a href="https://research-747993.gifthub.news/post/8026947315">Impact of Multiplayer Educational Games on Collaborative Problem-Solving Skills</a></h2>
  248.                            <p class="info">Game developers are the visionary architects behind the mesmerizing worlds and captivating narratives that define modern gaming experiences. Their tireless innovation and creativity have propelled the industry forward, delivering groundbreaking titles that blur the line between reality and fantasy, leaving players awestruck and eager for the next technological marvel.</p>
  249.                            <a href="https://research-747993.gifthub.news/post/8026947315" class="post-author d-flex align-items-center">
  250.                                <div class="author-pic">
  251.                                    <img src="https://x.gifthub.news/static/images/user/9.jpg" alt="Impact of Multiplayer Educational Games on Collaborative Problem-Solving Skills" title="Impact of Multiplayer Educational Games on Collaborative Problem-Solving Skills" class="lazyload">
  252.                                </div>
  253.                                <div class="text">
  254.                                    <strong>Brandon Barnes</strong>
  255.                                    <span>2025-02-01 published post</span>
  256.                                </div>
  257.                            </a>
  258.                        </div>
  259.                    </div>
  260.                </div>
  261.            </div>
  262.        </div>
  263.    </div>
  264.    <div class="py-5 bg-light mx-md-3 sec-subscribe">
  265.        <div class="container">
  266.            <div class="row">
  267.                <div class="col-lg-12">
  268.                    <h2 class="h4 fw-bold">Subscribe to newsletter</h2>
  269.                </div>
  270.            </div>
  271.            <form class="row">
  272.                <div class="col-md-8">
  273.                    <div class="mb-3 mb-md-0">
  274.                        <input type="email" class="form-control" placeholder="Enter your email">
  275.                    </div>
  276.                </div>
  277.                <div class="col-md-4 d-grid">
  278.                    <input type="submit" class="btn btn-primary" value="Subscribe">
  279.                </div>
  280.            </form>
  281.        </div>
  282.    </div>
  283.    <div class="site-footer">
  284.        <div class="container">
  285.            <div class="row justify-content-center copyright">
  286.                <div class="col-lg-7 text-center">
  287.                    <div class="widget">
  288.                        <p>Copyright &copy;
  289.                            <script>document.write(new Date().getFullYear());</script> All rights reserved.
  290.                        </p>
  291. <p>
  292.    < Top VPS Hosting Choice ><br>
  293.    <a href="https://evolution-host.com?ref=DQgZ6P" target="_blank">
  294.        <img src="https://x.gifthub.news/static/images/evolution-host.png" alt="Evolution Host" title="Evolution Host" class="evhost lazyload">
  295.    </a>
  296. </p>
  297.                    </div>
  298.                </div>
  299.            </div>
  300.        </div>
  301.    </div>
  302. </body>
  303.  
  304. </html>
Copyright © 2002-9 Sam Ruby, Mark Pilgrim, Joseph Walton, and Phil Ringnalda